Daniel 12:4 foretells that in the End Times knowledge shall be increased. That is often taken to be about Knowledge in general, the explosion of knowledge that has happened since the Industrial Revolution. But some have taken it to be about specifically knowledge of God's Word.
I say those two naturally go together. We today have lots of advantages in studying God's Word that didn't always exist. Today in debates people often get mad at you if you neglect to cite the exact Chapter and Verse, when Jesus didn't have that luxury, He just named the Prophet He was quoting and that had to be enough. Not to mention how the Internet and Computer Programs have made it easier then ever to do word searches and to check the original Greek and Hebrew, and compare variant manuscripts.
But even before all of that. The New Testament interprets some parts of The Hebrew Bible in ways that seemingly no Israelite ever thought of in the B.C. Era.
The Canon was closed I believe with the publication of The Book of Revelation. So it's a part of The Bible that never gets interpreted by other parts of The Bible, instead it is a key to helping us interpret other parts.
But I'm a Continuationist, I believe God does still inspire people, but those revelations have to be scrutinized against Scripture. Sometimes I think even the person who receives the revelation might mis-interpret it.
This has become a vital part of the Rapture Dispute. With people wondering why it took till the 19th Century for The Pre-Trib view (and by extension anything like Mid-Trib or Pre-Wrath) to be popularized, however many debatable hints at it before you might find.
This tactic conveniently ignores how Futurism in general was not popular in the Protestant world till the late 19th Century, their default Eschatology was Historicism.
For over a Thousand Years the Catholic Church kept most people from reading The Bible in their own language. After the Reformation started it still took awhile for Translations to be made, and arguably the first ones made weren't the best. So that's why it makes perfect sense that lots of valid interpretations of Scripture wouldn't be discovered or re-discovered till the 1600s or later.
Now there is a lot of mis-information about Darby. He first wrote out the basics of his Pre-Trib Rapture view in early 1827, before Margaret MacDonald had her vision in 1830, and also before Irving published his translation of Manuel Lucanza.
Still neither of those sources teach a Pre-Trib Rapture. MacDonald's account of her revelation has certain things left out of it when people make it seem like it could have inspired Darby's Pre-Trib view, like how she did say The Church would be persecuted by The Antichrist. Her vision does not lay out a clear chronology however, I feel it could be compatible with either Post-Trib or Mid-Trib, but certainly not Pre-Trib. Plus Darby said he thought her visions were Satanically inspired.
This whole "The Rapture must be false since it started with Darby" rhetoric definitely has an Anti-Continuationist tone to it. Darby's own account of how he first came to the idea makes it seem slightly like a divine revelation. And then they add the association with a controversial proto-Charismatic.
I think it's possible that Darby did receive a legit Revelation about Christ gathering His People before His Wrath is poured out. But then made many mistakes when trying to figure out how that fit into Scripture. In a way making the same key mistake Post-Tribbers make.
Because in my opinion, no amount of precedent for Post-Trib makes up for the fact that Post-Trib (in both it's Futurist and Historcist varieties) is based on an inherently wrong assumption, that Revelation 19 is the Second Coming. Pre-Tribers make the same mistake however when they say The Rapture is distinct from the Second Coming.
But I understand why this mistake would be so common. If you start your study of Bible Prophecy with Revelation, which many do, it's easy to see why one would make that mistake. I myself did originally which is why I used to be Post-Trib, though I was always distinct from most Post-Tribbers.
Morgan Edwards taught a form of Pre-Trib in the mid 18th Century, while also being one of the earliest Futurists of the English Speaking world.
So I still haven't given up on finding some obscure little known Ancient or Reformation era precedent for something similar to my Midway-Point view. But regardless it is not necessary.
My view on The Rapture is the one that correctly identifies where to find The Parusia in Revelation using Scripture to Interpret Scripture.
This Blog is retired, for now check out this one. https://materialisteschatology.blogspot.com/
Monday, February 26, 2018
Sunday, February 25, 2018
Pre-Tribbers mis-quoting old Historicists
A lot of the attempts of Pre-Tribbers to claim there were Pre-Tribbers before Darby involve a lot of mis-quoteing old Historicists, people who weren't even Futurists.
All these quotes tend to involve references to a "Great-Conflagration", that old Historicists like Joseph Mede, John Gill and Cotton Mather tended to place between the fulfillment of 1 Thessalonians 4 and the start of the Millenial Kingdom.
This "Great-Conflagration" is probably based on 2 Peter 3's talk of a coming destruction of the Earth by fire. One thing I've been struggling with is how this particular prophecy of Peter's does not at face value have an obvious place where it happens in Revelation.
Morgan Edwards was not a Historcist however, there are a couple sites out there trying to claim he was but that is easily refutable. I wanted to believe Edwards might have been Mid-Trib, but was forced to admit he was Pre-Trib, just not giving the Trib a full Seven Years.
It would be absurd to suggest any Historcist view on the timing of the Rapture is analogous to Pre-Trib, since they definitely place the Seals and Trumpets before the Rapture, and from examples I've seen also the Bowls of God's Wrath.
That of course is why a Post-Tribber might feel inclined to say that these Historicists were essentially Post-Trib. Well it's complicated, since not all these Puritan Historicists were even Pre-Millenial, at least a few flirted with Post-Millenialism.
But even when they are Pre-Millenial. Based on how I've defined my Midway Point Rapture model. It can be fair to say this "Great-Conflagration" equates to the idea of the Wrath not happening until we are taken out. Plus there is my past arguments (I'm now less sure on but kind of still lean towards) that the Church remains in Heaven until the descent of New Jerusalem.
A doctrine being new is not an argument against it being valid. Strangely enough I thought I'd already done a post specifically on that, but I guess I didn't. I'm gonna have to get to that. Update: Here it is.
Additional Update April 2020: Imminence
What I failed to get at the time is how being Hisotricist can allow you to be functionally exactly like Pre-Tribbers on Imminence. They technically agree with what Post-Tribbers and Pre-Wrath and my view says must come first, but to them those things have already happened.
All these quotes tend to involve references to a "Great-Conflagration", that old Historicists like Joseph Mede, John Gill and Cotton Mather tended to place between the fulfillment of 1 Thessalonians 4 and the start of the Millenial Kingdom.
This "Great-Conflagration" is probably based on 2 Peter 3's talk of a coming destruction of the Earth by fire. One thing I've been struggling with is how this particular prophecy of Peter's does not at face value have an obvious place where it happens in Revelation.
Morgan Edwards was not a Historcist however, there are a couple sites out there trying to claim he was but that is easily refutable. I wanted to believe Edwards might have been Mid-Trib, but was forced to admit he was Pre-Trib, just not giving the Trib a full Seven Years.
It would be absurd to suggest any Historcist view on the timing of the Rapture is analogous to Pre-Trib, since they definitely place the Seals and Trumpets before the Rapture, and from examples I've seen also the Bowls of God's Wrath.
That of course is why a Post-Tribber might feel inclined to say that these Historicists were essentially Post-Trib. Well it's complicated, since not all these Puritan Historicists were even Pre-Millenial, at least a few flirted with Post-Millenialism.
But even when they are Pre-Millenial. Based on how I've defined my Midway Point Rapture model. It can be fair to say this "Great-Conflagration" equates to the idea of the Wrath not happening until we are taken out. Plus there is my past arguments (I'm now less sure on but kind of still lean towards) that the Church remains in Heaven until the descent of New Jerusalem.
A doctrine being new is not an argument against it being valid. Strangely enough I thought I'd already done a post specifically on that, but I guess I didn't. I'm gonna have to get to that. Update: Here it is.
Additional Update April 2020: Imminence
What I failed to get at the time is how being Hisotricist can allow you to be functionally exactly like Pre-Tribbers on Imminence. They technically agree with what Post-Tribbers and Pre-Wrath and my view says must come first, but to them those things have already happened.
Saturday, February 24, 2018
Were Increase and Cotton Mather Pre-Trib?
This isn't me asking only to then answer myself, I honestly don't know. The easy to find online for free versions of their writings have not had their texts modernized and so are difficult to read. I tried once and gave up.
I've seen a number of websites cite Cotton Mather as being a Pre-Darby Pre-Tribber. Some may also mention his father Increase Mather, but not always. And I've never seen Increase mentioned without Cotton. So there is always Cotton and sometimes there is Increase.
However they have never actually quoted them, or even said what book of theirs they said it in. The only person I've seen actually quote them talking about The Rapture is a commentator on an article that didn't mention them at all citing them among people who they say were clearly not Pre-Trib.
The thing is, it's mainly people who are opposing Pre-Trib (and I would assume implicitly any other non Post-Trib view) who are citing them as such. It used to be the Post-Tribbers clung strongly to the not before Darby narrative, but there is a trend now of people willing to push it back to the Puritan era.
A lot of views on The Bible began or arguably were revived in the English Speaking world in the 17th Century. England was the largest and most prosperous nation where Protestantism had become the mainstream religion. It took a while for that issue to be settled, but by the Reign of King James England finally found peace, and early in his reign finally settled on what would for awhile be the default English Bible.
The Levelers and Diggers and others were the source of a lot of modern Biblical Based political theories that I'm certain many of these Post-Tribbers revere. Not to mention Roger Williams inventing the modern notion of Religious Liberty. So only if you're Catholic would you reject the idea that that is naturally a time to expect new Biblical ideas to be discovered or rediscovered. Back before the 19th Century, Historicism was the standard Eschatology of the Protestant world, though some early Protestants followed Augustinian Amillenialism.
The agenda behind associating Pre-Trib with Cotton Mather is to then engage in a guilt by association smear campaign against Pre-Trib. Because both father and son Mathers were involved with and sometimes partly blamed for the Salem Witch Trials. Only a few of these sites mentioned that association, but I suspect they all know that a Wikipedia search for their names will lead to that coming up. Especially since some even say outright they were the first Pre-Tribbers.
The thing is every doctrine has some guilt by association with it. If you hold the Calcedonian position of how Christ's Divinity and Humanity relate to each other (which is the presumed position of all major Western Denominations, I personally am undecided), or the Miaphsyte one. Then you subscribe to a doctrine that was popularized by Cyril of Alexandria, Emperor Theodosius II and his sister Pulcheria. Who were involved in persecuting Jews and other non-Christians including the murder of Hypatia.
But on the subject of the Salem Witch Trails, the Mathers believed in the supernatural and thought what was going on was supernatural, which was hardly rare. But they actually felt things got out of hand and opposed using "Spectral Evidence" as the sole basis for convictions. Increase said something that reminds me of a quote of Voltaire I used to cite a lot, "It were better that ten suspected witches should escape, than that one innocent person should be condemned".
Still I do not approve of what they did.
But returning to the subject at hand. I don't know when they placed the Parusia. I do vaguely remember them being Zionists from when I tried to read them before, which post-Darby has been strongly linked to Pre-Trib and least popular among Post-Trib. But I don't know for certain.
Update: Well I have found a link to read Cotton Mather's The Threefold Paradise. For one thing their views were rather Historicist, but Cotton wound up developing something rather unique.
Without even getting to the book itself yet, the Introduction makes clear where the basis for a Pre-Trib accusation lies. It's actually quite interesting reading it's analysis of how Mather's views changed over time.
Ironically he developed his belief that the Saints would be taken to Heaven to escape a "Great Conflagration" at the same time he abandoned his long held belief in a coming mass conversation of The Jews. Making him certainly not compatible with modern Pre-Tribulationism, if it's accurate to call it Pre-Trib or even Pre-Wrath at all.
It seems one of the issues he struggled with was a basis for a popular hypothesis that a Supernatural Appearance of Christ would trigger their mass conversion. He should have considered the option that when Jesus comes to take the Saints to Heaven, is that appearance.
Indeed I feel like maybe if I could have explained my basic Midway Point Rapture view argument to him, that it could have solved this confusion and made this rather contrived "Golden Key" of Bible Prophecy he developed unnecessary.
I was also surprised to learn there was a time when the Duel Fulfillment argument was considered insufficiently literal, and something that supposedly existed only to help the New Testament. Judaism has it in some contexts as well, in fact if you reject it there is no basis for a coming Messiah Ben-David at all, cause Nathan's Prophecy in II Samuel 7 was clearly first fulfilled by Solomon.
I've seen a number of websites cite Cotton Mather as being a Pre-Darby Pre-Tribber. Some may also mention his father Increase Mather, but not always. And I've never seen Increase mentioned without Cotton. So there is always Cotton and sometimes there is Increase.
However they have never actually quoted them, or even said what book of theirs they said it in. The only person I've seen actually quote them talking about The Rapture is a commentator on an article that didn't mention them at all citing them among people who they say were clearly not Pre-Trib.
Increase Mather (1639-1723): “That part of the world [Europe] was to be principally the Seat of the CHURCH of Christ during the Reign of Antichrist” (Ichabod, p. 64).The quote from Cotton there I don't see how it'd be Rapture relevant at all. The Increase quote is definitely not compatible with Pre-Trib but it could fit Mid-Trib or Pre-Wrath.
Cotton Mather (1663-1728): “…that New Jerusalem, whereto the Church is to be advanced, when the Mystical Babylon shall be fallen” (The Wonders of the Invisible World, p. 3).
The thing is, it's mainly people who are opposing Pre-Trib (and I would assume implicitly any other non Post-Trib view) who are citing them as such. It used to be the Post-Tribbers clung strongly to the not before Darby narrative, but there is a trend now of people willing to push it back to the Puritan era.
A lot of views on The Bible began or arguably were revived in the English Speaking world in the 17th Century. England was the largest and most prosperous nation where Protestantism had become the mainstream religion. It took a while for that issue to be settled, but by the Reign of King James England finally found peace, and early in his reign finally settled on what would for awhile be the default English Bible.
The Levelers and Diggers and others were the source of a lot of modern Biblical Based political theories that I'm certain many of these Post-Tribbers revere. Not to mention Roger Williams inventing the modern notion of Religious Liberty. So only if you're Catholic would you reject the idea that that is naturally a time to expect new Biblical ideas to be discovered or rediscovered. Back before the 19th Century, Historicism was the standard Eschatology of the Protestant world, though some early Protestants followed Augustinian Amillenialism.
The agenda behind associating Pre-Trib with Cotton Mather is to then engage in a guilt by association smear campaign against Pre-Trib. Because both father and son Mathers were involved with and sometimes partly blamed for the Salem Witch Trials. Only a few of these sites mentioned that association, but I suspect they all know that a Wikipedia search for their names will lead to that coming up. Especially since some even say outright they were the first Pre-Tribbers.
The thing is every doctrine has some guilt by association with it. If you hold the Calcedonian position of how Christ's Divinity and Humanity relate to each other (which is the presumed position of all major Western Denominations, I personally am undecided), or the Miaphsyte one. Then you subscribe to a doctrine that was popularized by Cyril of Alexandria, Emperor Theodosius II and his sister Pulcheria. Who were involved in persecuting Jews and other non-Christians including the murder of Hypatia.
But on the subject of the Salem Witch Trails, the Mathers believed in the supernatural and thought what was going on was supernatural, which was hardly rare. But they actually felt things got out of hand and opposed using "Spectral Evidence" as the sole basis for convictions. Increase said something that reminds me of a quote of Voltaire I used to cite a lot, "It were better that ten suspected witches should escape, than that one innocent person should be condemned".
Still I do not approve of what they did.
But returning to the subject at hand. I don't know when they placed the Parusia. I do vaguely remember them being Zionists from when I tried to read them before, which post-Darby has been strongly linked to Pre-Trib and least popular among Post-Trib. But I don't know for certain.
Update: Well I have found a link to read Cotton Mather's The Threefold Paradise. For one thing their views were rather Historicist, but Cotton wound up developing something rather unique.
Without even getting to the book itself yet, the Introduction makes clear where the basis for a Pre-Trib accusation lies. It's actually quite interesting reading it's analysis of how Mather's views changed over time.
Ironically he developed his belief that the Saints would be taken to Heaven to escape a "Great Conflagration" at the same time he abandoned his long held belief in a coming mass conversation of The Jews. Making him certainly not compatible with modern Pre-Tribulationism, if it's accurate to call it Pre-Trib or even Pre-Wrath at all.
It seems one of the issues he struggled with was a basis for a popular hypothesis that a Supernatural Appearance of Christ would trigger their mass conversion. He should have considered the option that when Jesus comes to take the Saints to Heaven, is that appearance.
Indeed I feel like maybe if I could have explained my basic Midway Point Rapture view argument to him, that it could have solved this confusion and made this rather contrived "Golden Key" of Bible Prophecy he developed unnecessary.
I was also surprised to learn there was a time when the Duel Fulfillment argument was considered insufficiently literal, and something that supposedly existed only to help the New Testament. Judaism has it in some contexts as well, in fact if you reject it there is no basis for a coming Messiah Ben-David at all, cause Nathan's Prophecy in II Samuel 7 was clearly first fulfilled by Solomon.
Sunday, February 11, 2018
My relationship with the Islamic Antichrist theory is complex
To a large extent it's a theory I don't want to be true. All the contemporary political agendas and fear mongering that are assumed to be behind the desire to create an Islamic Antichrist theory are things I oppose. I'm politically a left learning libertarian, I don't think Islam is an inherently more violent religion then most. And I certainly didn't vote for Donald Trump.
It would be nice if speculating that these Prophecies could be fulfilled by a Muslim didn't connect to Anti-Muslim or Anti-Arab bigotry any more then the Nicolai Carpathea theory is bigotry against Blonde Haired Blue Eyed Europeans. But we don't live in a perfect world. In western fiction, unless the author is explicitly trying to be progressive, white villains are never assumed to be evil because of their whiteness, but with minority villains that subtext is always there a little whether the writer intends that or not. And it's not a coincidence that popular theories about the Antichrist echo those Super Villain tropes. When he's White he's Lex Luthor or Chancellor Palpatine, but when he's not he's Fu Manchu.
Fortunately I'm an Evangelical Universalist now, I don't think people who accept the Mark are damned to hell for all of eternity, I don't even think the Antichrist and False Prophet themselves will be. Therefore I need not view them as cartoon villains. So I certainly don't want any Antichrist theory I might advocate to be viewed as demonizing any people groups who would share either a spiritual or physical kinship with that hypothetical Antichrist.
There is nothing in The Bible that says The Antichrist will follow a religion that won't exist till over 500 years after Revelation was written. But in general The Bible doesn't talk about The beast's religion, it says he will in some way deify himself at some point, but that doesn't tell us what his original religious affiliation will be.
There are plenty of Prophecies that can be taken as geographical clues, and most of them point to places that have been Islamic regions for a long time now and aren't likely to change any time soon. Babylon/Assyria, Edom, Egypt, Syria, ect. Only Greece and Rome aren't, but those don't have any solid witnesses outside symbolic visions in Daniel and Revelation drawing on Daniel.
And my research has lead me to evidence that Arabia itself has a role to play in prophecy. It's research I've been doing mainly for the purpose of hoping to emphasize positive common ground between Islam and the Judeo-Christian tradition. But a lot of the good things in The Bible have a dark-side as well. And so even the evidence for Sinai and Kadesh-Barnea possibly being in Arabia, leads to reminders of the Golden Calf incident and Korah's Rebellion, and what typological relevance they could have for the Image of the Beast and the references to the Wilderness in Revelation.
Back to the subject of Greece and Rome, the Roman Empire grew to include many of the now Islamic regions alluded to above, and parts of southern Italy were under Islamic Control for some of the middle ages. And much of what Greece meant in Antiquity is now part of Turkey. Not to mention how Islam is a fast growing religion in modern Europe.
Those statistics are often exaggerated as part of Islamiiphobic fear mongering from the Right. But are also something the Left will point out as a good sign that the world is becoming more diverse. I don't care one way or the other, and am only interested in terms of what it might mean for Bible Prophecy.
Now my recent post about The Beast possibly using the Name of YHWH or a Yah Theophoric name, might at first glance conflict with an Islamic Antichrist view since Muslims are often hostile to that name. However there are some exceptions to that general trend, particularly in Shia traditions.
The way I would make an Islamic Antichrist argument is different from the major people doing so already like Walid Shabbat and Perry Stone. Not just in terms of my tone towards Islam in general, but also in the Biblical Arguments I'd make. Which is made clear in my past posts on this tag.
I still don't consider it the most likely option, the theory that The Beast will be teaching something similar to the Hebrew Roots movement is still more likely in my view. But it's become the second mostly likely model I think. Certainly more Biblically supportable then the Left Behind model.
It would be nice if speculating that these Prophecies could be fulfilled by a Muslim didn't connect to Anti-Muslim or Anti-Arab bigotry any more then the Nicolai Carpathea theory is bigotry against Blonde Haired Blue Eyed Europeans. But we don't live in a perfect world. In western fiction, unless the author is explicitly trying to be progressive, white villains are never assumed to be evil because of their whiteness, but with minority villains that subtext is always there a little whether the writer intends that or not. And it's not a coincidence that popular theories about the Antichrist echo those Super Villain tropes. When he's White he's Lex Luthor or Chancellor Palpatine, but when he's not he's Fu Manchu.
Fortunately I'm an Evangelical Universalist now, I don't think people who accept the Mark are damned to hell for all of eternity, I don't even think the Antichrist and False Prophet themselves will be. Therefore I need not view them as cartoon villains. So I certainly don't want any Antichrist theory I might advocate to be viewed as demonizing any people groups who would share either a spiritual or physical kinship with that hypothetical Antichrist.
There is nothing in The Bible that says The Antichrist will follow a religion that won't exist till over 500 years after Revelation was written. But in general The Bible doesn't talk about The beast's religion, it says he will in some way deify himself at some point, but that doesn't tell us what his original religious affiliation will be.
There are plenty of Prophecies that can be taken as geographical clues, and most of them point to places that have been Islamic regions for a long time now and aren't likely to change any time soon. Babylon/Assyria, Edom, Egypt, Syria, ect. Only Greece and Rome aren't, but those don't have any solid witnesses outside symbolic visions in Daniel and Revelation drawing on Daniel.
And my research has lead me to evidence that Arabia itself has a role to play in prophecy. It's research I've been doing mainly for the purpose of hoping to emphasize positive common ground between Islam and the Judeo-Christian tradition. But a lot of the good things in The Bible have a dark-side as well. And so even the evidence for Sinai and Kadesh-Barnea possibly being in Arabia, leads to reminders of the Golden Calf incident and Korah's Rebellion, and what typological relevance they could have for the Image of the Beast and the references to the Wilderness in Revelation.
Back to the subject of Greece and Rome, the Roman Empire grew to include many of the now Islamic regions alluded to above, and parts of southern Italy were under Islamic Control for some of the middle ages. And much of what Greece meant in Antiquity is now part of Turkey. Not to mention how Islam is a fast growing religion in modern Europe.
Those statistics are often exaggerated as part of Islamiiphobic fear mongering from the Right. But are also something the Left will point out as a good sign that the world is becoming more diverse. I don't care one way or the other, and am only interested in terms of what it might mean for Bible Prophecy.
Now my recent post about The Beast possibly using the Name of YHWH or a Yah Theophoric name, might at first glance conflict with an Islamic Antichrist view since Muslims are often hostile to that name. However there are some exceptions to that general trend, particularly in Shia traditions.
( إذا أذَن الإمام , دعا الله بإسمه العبراني ( كتاب الغيبة للنعمانيAnd another quote about the Imam's own Name implies it'll be treated similarly to the Holy Name.
Al-Mufadhal ibn Umar is reported to have said that Abu Abdullah [a.s.] (Shia’s 6th Imams) said: “When the Imam (Mahdi) makes a call (for prayer), he will supplicate to God using God's Hebrew name...” (Al-Numani, Al-Ghayba , p.326)
مهدي الشيعة لا يحل ذكر اسمه ومن سماه ملعون (بحار الأنوار 51/33)And these quotes are emphasized by that Sunni Websites that thinks the Dajjal will be the Shiite Imam Mahdi.
According to Al-Majlisi’s Bihar Al-Anwar, Vol. 51, page 33, it is not permissible to mention the name of the Shia’s Mahdi and whoever refers to him by his name shall be cursed.
The way I would make an Islamic Antichrist argument is different from the major people doing so already like Walid Shabbat and Perry Stone. Not just in terms of my tone towards Islam in general, but also in the Biblical Arguments I'd make. Which is made clear in my past posts on this tag.
I still don't consider it the most likely option, the theory that The Beast will be teaching something similar to the Hebrew Roots movement is still more likely in my view. But it's become the second mostly likely model I think. Certainly more Biblically supportable then the Left Behind model.
Saturday, February 10, 2018
The Name of the Beast could be a Yah Theophoric Name
This theory I'm proposing is compatible with my prior Iapetos theory, since in that post I'd suggested how the name Iapetos could be re-interpreted as a Yah Theophoric name by a Jewish Messiah claimant using it. But it could be compatible with other theories too. In fact it could be just a form of the name YHWH manipulated to have a Greek Numerical value of 666, but I have not yet discovered a form that would work for that.
Revelation 13 at the end mentions the Name of the Beast that has a Numerical value of 666. But earlier the chapter also mentioned the "Name of Blasphemy" that is on each head of the Beast. I have a hunch that could be the same name.
Throughout The Bible however, the primary name that is associated with Blasphemy is The Holy Name, which I prefer to pronounce Yahuah, like in Leviticus 24. It's also one of The Ten Commandments to not use that Name in vain. Blasphemy does include the name being claimed by one to whom it doesn't belong.
There are aspects of the Image of the Beast narrative in Revelation 13 that could lead one to see it as a sort of repeat of the Golden Calf incident. Well remember they sort of called that Calf by the name of YHWH in Exodus 32 verses 4 through 6.
This potentially goes along with what I've suggested before that The Beast may in fact be enforcing a Torah based system.
A Torah basis for the Mark of the Beast system possibly exists in the same verses that are the basis of the Tefillin tradition. Exodus 13:9 and 16, Deuteronomy 6:8 and 11:18. But I could add to that the Crown of the High Priest which Exodus 28:36 and 39:30 says will have "Holiness to Yahuah" engraved on it. And that verse also uses the word "Signet".
There are a few Biblical Figures viewed as Types of The Antichrist who also have Yah Theophoric names.
Adonijah who attempted to usurp the throne from Solomon.
Solomon himself has been viewed as a Type of the Antichrist when he backslid into Idolatry. In which case it's useful to remember that the name Nathan gave Solomon was Jedediah in 2 Samuel 12:25, which means Beloved of Yah.
All three named children of Ahab and Jezebel had Yah Theophoric names, Ahaziah, Jehoram and Athaliah.
But perhaps most interestingly is Jehu who I've spoken about on this Blog a lot already. Jehu is the closest any Human in the Bible comes to simply being named YHWH, his name is also four letters in the Hebrew, the only difference is the second Heh is instead an Aleph making it YHWA, YHWO or YHWU. And it means "Yahu is He", which could be manipulated to mean "He is Yahu".
The Septuagint spelling of Jehu is Iota-Omicron-Upsilion, which is Iou, which often gets transliterated into English as just Ju. And in Latin it's usually Iehu. Iou has a numerical value of 480, so it's just a matter of somehow adding 186 to it. But it's also a spelling you can get from dropping half the letters out of Iesous/Jesus.
Revelation 13 at the end mentions the Name of the Beast that has a Numerical value of 666. But earlier the chapter also mentioned the "Name of Blasphemy" that is on each head of the Beast. I have a hunch that could be the same name.
Throughout The Bible however, the primary name that is associated with Blasphemy is The Holy Name, which I prefer to pronounce Yahuah, like in Leviticus 24. It's also one of The Ten Commandments to not use that Name in vain. Blasphemy does include the name being claimed by one to whom it doesn't belong.
There are aspects of the Image of the Beast narrative in Revelation 13 that could lead one to see it as a sort of repeat of the Golden Calf incident. Well remember they sort of called that Calf by the name of YHWH in Exodus 32 verses 4 through 6.
This potentially goes along with what I've suggested before that The Beast may in fact be enforcing a Torah based system.
A Torah basis for the Mark of the Beast system possibly exists in the same verses that are the basis of the Tefillin tradition. Exodus 13:9 and 16, Deuteronomy 6:8 and 11:18. But I could add to that the Crown of the High Priest which Exodus 28:36 and 39:30 says will have "Holiness to Yahuah" engraved on it. And that verse also uses the word "Signet".
There are a few Biblical Figures viewed as Types of The Antichrist who also have Yah Theophoric names.
Adonijah who attempted to usurp the throne from Solomon.
Solomon himself has been viewed as a Type of the Antichrist when he backslid into Idolatry. In which case it's useful to remember that the name Nathan gave Solomon was Jedediah in 2 Samuel 12:25, which means Beloved of Yah.
All three named children of Ahab and Jezebel had Yah Theophoric names, Ahaziah, Jehoram and Athaliah.
But perhaps most interestingly is Jehu who I've spoken about on this Blog a lot already. Jehu is the closest any Human in the Bible comes to simply being named YHWH, his name is also four letters in the Hebrew, the only difference is the second Heh is instead an Aleph making it YHWA, YHWO or YHWU. And it means "Yahu is He", which could be manipulated to mean "He is Yahu".
The Septuagint spelling of Jehu is Iota-Omicron-Upsilion, which is Iou, which often gets transliterated into English as just Ju. And in Latin it's usually Iehu. Iou has a numerical value of 480, so it's just a matter of somehow adding 186 to it. But it's also a spelling you can get from dropping half the letters out of Iesous/Jesus.
Thursday, February 1, 2018
Paniym Eretz, The Face of The Earth.
Paniym Eretz is a Hebrew phrase translated in the KJV as either "The Face of The Earth", "The Face of The Whole Earth", or "The Face of all The Earth". Greek translations of the phrase are used in Luke 21:35 and Acts 17:26.
I've read some material on a website I don't want to link to that argued Noah's Flood was just local. And insists they are taking The Bible perfectly literally in doing so.
Now I agree entirely that the word Eretz is also translated land and is often used of more specific locations, a fact I like to point out when addressing Flat Earthers. It's used of the Land of Israel, and the Land of Mizraim and so on.
However Genesis 1 definitely uses it of all dry land when saying God separated the land from the waters.
The Flood is described as covering the Face of The Earth in Genesis 6:7 and 7:3-4 and 8:9. It is this expression I feel must mean the entire surface of the Earth. And I feel I can back that up from passages I will cite later.
But this Website says the Face of The Earth must mean something more specific since Genesis 4:14 says Cain was banished from the Face of the Earth, and yet is also a fugitive and a vagabond in the Earth. However this website contradicts it's own logic by saying the Flood can be considered "Universal" because it covered all the lands that descendants of Adam (of Genesis 2) lived in up to that time. They specifically apply it to Mesopotamia.
Paul used it in Greece in a context where he clearly meant it to be understood that where he was counted as part of it.
Isaiah 23:17 says "And it shall come to pass after the end of seventy years, that Yahuah will visit Tyre, and she shall turn to her hire, and shall commit fornication with all the kingdoms of the world upon the face of the earth.".
Other Prophets say Israel was scattered across the Face of the Earth.
Genesis 41:56 and numerous uses of the phrase in Exodus through Deuteronomy clearly use it in a way that includes Mizraim (where ever that was) and the lands Israel wondered in for 40 years.
Genesis 11:4-8&9 utterly contradicts limiting it to Mesopotamia.
I'm kind of starting to wonder if maybe Paniym Eretz is a Hebrew equivalent of phrases like Midgard in Norse Mythology from which comes the term Middle Earth (Tolkien didn't invent it), and Ashihara no Nakatsukuni (The middle country of reed beds) in Japanese Mythology. A term that can be viewed as technically more specific then the entirety of what "Earth" means, and yet still effectively the entire world as we know it.
This could be an expression where the context is key to the point being made. Cain was banished from the world he knew up to that time. But that doesn't change that the obvious intent of the Flood narrative is still that the Flood covered everything.
However there is one possible idea I can't help but flirt with. And that is that maybe Cain was banished from the Face of our Earth, but the Land of Nod ("Land" in that phrase is also Eretz) is another planet? It's described as "east" of Eden, but is a specific fairly rare form of the word for east, qidmah. Remember the Sun, Moon and Stars rise in the East and set in the West. And the Hebrew words for East are also sometimes translated things like before and ancient.
That's a bit of a stretch I admit. But I've already argued for other cases of The Bible possibly alluding to humans traveling to outer Space.
I've read some material on a website I don't want to link to that argued Noah's Flood was just local. And insists they are taking The Bible perfectly literally in doing so.
Now I agree entirely that the word Eretz is also translated land and is often used of more specific locations, a fact I like to point out when addressing Flat Earthers. It's used of the Land of Israel, and the Land of Mizraim and so on.
However Genesis 1 definitely uses it of all dry land when saying God separated the land from the waters.
The Flood is described as covering the Face of The Earth in Genesis 6:7 and 7:3-4 and 8:9. It is this expression I feel must mean the entire surface of the Earth. And I feel I can back that up from passages I will cite later.
But this Website says the Face of The Earth must mean something more specific since Genesis 4:14 says Cain was banished from the Face of the Earth, and yet is also a fugitive and a vagabond in the Earth. However this website contradicts it's own logic by saying the Flood can be considered "Universal" because it covered all the lands that descendants of Adam (of Genesis 2) lived in up to that time. They specifically apply it to Mesopotamia.
Paul used it in Greece in a context where he clearly meant it to be understood that where he was counted as part of it.
Isaiah 23:17 says "And it shall come to pass after the end of seventy years, that Yahuah will visit Tyre, and she shall turn to her hire, and shall commit fornication with all the kingdoms of the world upon the face of the earth.".
Other Prophets say Israel was scattered across the Face of the Earth.
Genesis 41:56 and numerous uses of the phrase in Exodus through Deuteronomy clearly use it in a way that includes Mizraim (where ever that was) and the lands Israel wondered in for 40 years.
Genesis 11:4-8&9 utterly contradicts limiting it to Mesopotamia.
I'm kind of starting to wonder if maybe Paniym Eretz is a Hebrew equivalent of phrases like Midgard in Norse Mythology from which comes the term Middle Earth (Tolkien didn't invent it), and Ashihara no Nakatsukuni (The middle country of reed beds) in Japanese Mythology. A term that can be viewed as technically more specific then the entirety of what "Earth" means, and yet still effectively the entire world as we know it.
This could be an expression where the context is key to the point being made. Cain was banished from the world he knew up to that time. But that doesn't change that the obvious intent of the Flood narrative is still that the Flood covered everything.
However there is one possible idea I can't help but flirt with. And that is that maybe Cain was banished from the Face of our Earth, but the Land of Nod ("Land" in that phrase is also Eretz) is another planet? It's described as "east" of Eden, but is a specific fairly rare form of the word for east, qidmah. Remember the Sun, Moon and Stars rise in the East and set in the West. And the Hebrew words for East are also sometimes translated things like before and ancient.
That's a bit of a stretch I admit. But I've already argued for other cases of The Bible possibly alluding to humans traveling to outer Space.
Thursday, January 11, 2018
A Slice of the Tree of Life
So I've talked a lot about my view that what Christians should be looking forward to is The Resurrection, not an "After Life". That the perfect Utopia we are promised is not contemporary Heaven but This World restored to something like how it was before the fall.
That to me is the true point of the difference between The Gospel and Paganism is that Pagan myths like those of Gilgamesh, Orpheus or Izanami and Izanagi are about accepting death as a natural part of Life, while The Gospel promises that no Death will be defeated and one day no longer exist. The Second Death is the Death or Death.
Many people who aren't Christians however view neither what I just described or the more casual Christian understanding of the "After Life" as desirable. They feel it is grossly naïve to think such a condition would be a good thing. In Season 4 of Angel, (the spin off of Buffy The Vampire Slayer), what Jasmine is trying to accomplish was essentially how Joss Whedon views Revelation 21 and 22.
I get the sense that at least some Western viewers of Anime probably have the same view about Human Instrumentality in Neon Genesis Evangelion and End of Evangelion (and the many evil schemes in Anime since that are kind of similar, like most recently *Spoiler Alert*what the Taisha wanted to do in Yuki Yuna Is A Hero season 2). Though there is certainly no Biblical Basis for the rejection of Individuality inherent in that plan. It's far more likely that it's The Beast and the False Prophet trying to achieve something like that with their Mark system.
Back on topic, the argument for why this should be viewed as bad is typically that there is no freedom or growth in a such world, that conflict and difficulty is necessary for that. (So it's funny then that sometimes the exact same people make the "why does God allow Evil to exist" argument).
It's pretty difficult for us to even imagine what such a world would be like. But I definitely view that criticism as an over simplification. For one thing there is this Quote from Revelation 22:2
I feel like these criticisms of the world presented in Revelation 21&22 (The Millennium in chapter 20 I don't even view as a true Utopia, but more as a Benevolent Dystopia. Has that term been used before or did I just invent it?), however morally they word it, essentially comes down to them saying they think it would be BORING. Like the common rather tong in cheek presentation of traditional heaven as us just sitting around all day on clouds playing harps while hell is a party.
I don't want to be bored either. I used to spend a lot of time radically declaring Superman Re[dacted] the worst movie ever made because to me it is the most boring. I am confident however that the New Heaven and New Earth will not be boring, but I've struggled with finding a good way to explain how. till today.
Pause and Select is an Anime Analysis YouTube Channel. I just a little while ago, on the night of January 10/11th 2018, watched their four part series on Japanese Apocalypticism in Anime titled Understanding Disaster.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL3itZ8UCAizGphd5_cOFylS38JFTV3-Ne
One mistake Pause and Select makes is that K-On! in particular is not lacking narrative. Digibro's praise of the show is all about it's subtle narrative arch and character development. Meaning there is growth. But it's not a conflict driven narrative, that is the point. I'm surprised this video didn't mention Aria.(Aria could be interesting in light of my theory that The Bible foretells colonization of Outer Space.) It doesn't mention Girl's Last Tour because it was published over a year ago.
This genre of Anime has been my favorite for awhile now, for many reasons, and I think Lucky Star is it's Citizen Kane. But watching this video just today caused it to click to me how maybe these Anime can also help me explain how the New Heaven and New Earth won't be boring. In theory these Anime exist in the present world and so we don't immediately think of them as being Utopic. But really they are narrative Utopias.
The video goes on to talk about other Apocalyptic Anime that looks more cynically on the Slice of Life genre. But because of my Faith in The Bible, I know such a stable future will one day come.
Since I think this post may attract some Anime fans not familiar with what I usually talk about. I want to add a reminder here that I have become a Universalist, and so this coming Utopic Shin-Sekai will be enjoyed by everyone, not just believers. Even Nihilistic Atheists like Digibro.
Update August 2019: I just re-watched much of Star Trek Generations, and it occurred to me how the Nexus in that film is also something that can possibly be read as a cynical view of "Heaven".
I've always liked the scene after Kirk makes that jump with the Horse, saying how it terrified him every-time but just now, because he knew it wasn't real. And that's why it's important to me to stress that the real "Heaven" is this world as it was meant to be not some alternate realm where there is only spirit and no physicality.
I think in the New Heaven and New Earth it would be possible to fail to make that jump, and that doing so would hurt, a lot, and maybe it'd be months before you've recovered enough to try again. It's just that there will no death.
Now you may think "that's not taking literally the "No Pain" in Revelation 21:4", the Greek word used there is "Ponos" which the Strongs (Number 4192) says more accurately means "Anguish" or "Toil", it's root is "Penes" (number 3993) which is often translated "Poor". So I think a specific type of "Pain" is what's meant there.
The only other times "Ponos" is used is in Revelation 16:10-11, where the context is the "Pain" the Kingdom of the beast experiences when it is covered in Darkness after the Fifth Bowl is poured out. I'm honestly starting to think maybe this word should be translated "Poverty". Also the word translated "Sores" in Revelation 16 is elsewhere in Scripture used only in Luke 16:20-21 talking about the Beggar Lazaurs.
But more importantly then that, the "anguish" meaning can be taken as meaning it's emotional pain, psychological suffering.
That to me is the true point of the difference between The Gospel and Paganism is that Pagan myths like those of Gilgamesh, Orpheus or Izanami and Izanagi are about accepting death as a natural part of Life, while The Gospel promises that no Death will be defeated and one day no longer exist. The Second Death is the Death or Death.
Many people who aren't Christians however view neither what I just described or the more casual Christian understanding of the "After Life" as desirable. They feel it is grossly naïve to think such a condition would be a good thing. In Season 4 of Angel, (the spin off of Buffy The Vampire Slayer), what Jasmine is trying to accomplish was essentially how Joss Whedon views Revelation 21 and 22.
I get the sense that at least some Western viewers of Anime probably have the same view about Human Instrumentality in Neon Genesis Evangelion and End of Evangelion (and the many evil schemes in Anime since that are kind of similar, like most recently *Spoiler Alert*
Back on topic, the argument for why this should be viewed as bad is typically that there is no freedom or growth in a such world, that conflict and difficulty is necessary for that. (So it's funny then that sometimes the exact same people make the "why does God allow Evil to exist" argument).
It's pretty difficult for us to even imagine what such a world would be like. But I definitely view that criticism as an over simplification. For one thing there is this Quote from Revelation 22:2
"the tree of life, which bare twelve manner of fruits, and yielded her fruit every month: and the leaves of the tree were for the healing of the nations."Emphasis on the word Healing. This shows that things are not exactly done. And I personally believe new children will be born during this era as well. A certain thing Jesus said about the Resurrection in Matthew 22 is commonly misunderstood ignoring Jesus actual point. Adam and Eve were supposed to be fruitful and multiply, so if we're restored to that state, it includes that command.
I feel like these criticisms of the world presented in Revelation 21&22 (The Millennium in chapter 20 I don't even view as a true Utopia, but more as a Benevolent Dystopia. Has that term been used before or did I just invent it?), however morally they word it, essentially comes down to them saying they think it would be BORING. Like the common rather tong in cheek presentation of traditional heaven as us just sitting around all day on clouds playing harps while hell is a party.
I don't want to be bored either. I used to spend a lot of time radically declaring Superman Re[dacted] the worst movie ever made because to me it is the most boring. I am confident however that the New Heaven and New Earth will not be boring, but I've struggled with finding a good way to explain how. till today.
Pause and Select is an Anime Analysis YouTube Channel. I just a little while ago, on the night of January 10/11th 2018, watched their four part series on Japanese Apocalypticism in Anime titled Understanding Disaster.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL3itZ8UCAizGphd5_cOFylS38JFTV3-Ne
The fourth and final part is what's primarily relevant to what I have to say here. But the first three parts should be watched first for context, it is all interesting stuff. (When talking about Akira, the observation about Akira being the object of worship but Tetsuo being the one really running things happened to remind me of my own re-evaluation of the relation between The Beast and the False Prophet).
In the fourth and final part they make a connection between the development of Apocalypticism in Anime and a certain genre of Anime. They don't use this term in the video, but the genre in question is often most commonly called "Slice of Life". Fortunately much of the narration is subtitled in the video, especially when quoting someone else. So here is a pretty and informative screen-cap.
Compare that to Revelation 21:4."And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away."Another key word used in this portion of the video is "healing", other videos about this genre also associate it with healing and soothing. But to me and many other fans they are absolutely not boring. In fact I've often come to find conflict driven narratives to be boring.
One mistake Pause and Select makes is that K-On! in particular is not lacking narrative. Digibro's praise of the show is all about it's subtle narrative arch and character development. Meaning there is growth. But it's not a conflict driven narrative, that is the point. I'm surprised this video didn't mention Aria.(Aria could be interesting in light of my theory that The Bible foretells colonization of Outer Space.) It doesn't mention Girl's Last Tour because it was published over a year ago.
This genre of Anime has been my favorite for awhile now, for many reasons, and I think Lucky Star is it's Citizen Kane. But watching this video just today caused it to click to me how maybe these Anime can also help me explain how the New Heaven and New Earth won't be boring. In theory these Anime exist in the present world and so we don't immediately think of them as being Utopic. But really they are narrative Utopias.
The video goes on to talk about other Apocalyptic Anime that looks more cynically on the Slice of Life genre. But because of my Faith in The Bible, I know such a stable future will one day come.
Since I think this post may attract some Anime fans not familiar with what I usually talk about. I want to add a reminder here that I have become a Universalist, and so this coming Utopic Shin-Sekai will be enjoyed by everyone, not just believers. Even Nihilistic Atheists like Digibro.
Update August 2019: I just re-watched much of Star Trek Generations, and it occurred to me how the Nexus in that film is also something that can possibly be read as a cynical view of "Heaven".
I've always liked the scene after Kirk makes that jump with the Horse, saying how it terrified him every-time but just now, because he knew it wasn't real. And that's why it's important to me to stress that the real "Heaven" is this world as it was meant to be not some alternate realm where there is only spirit and no physicality.
I think in the New Heaven and New Earth it would be possible to fail to make that jump, and that doing so would hurt, a lot, and maybe it'd be months before you've recovered enough to try again. It's just that there will no death.
Now you may think "that's not taking literally the "No Pain" in Revelation 21:4", the Greek word used there is "Ponos" which the Strongs (Number 4192) says more accurately means "Anguish" or "Toil", it's root is "Penes" (number 3993) which is often translated "Poor". So I think a specific type of "Pain" is what's meant there.
The only other times "Ponos" is used is in Revelation 16:10-11, where the context is the "Pain" the Kingdom of the beast experiences when it is covered in Darkness after the Fifth Bowl is poured out. I'm honestly starting to think maybe this word should be translated "Poverty". Also the word translated "Sores" in Revelation 16 is elsewhere in Scripture used only in Luke 16:20-21 talking about the Beggar Lazaurs.
But more importantly then that, the "anguish" meaning can be taken as meaning it's emotional pain, psychological suffering.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
